Many doctors dislike Medicare Advantage Plans because they involve more administrative work, lower reimbursement rates, and less clinical autonomy compared to traditional Medicare. Doctors must obtain prior authorizations for tests and referrals, follow strict utilization rules, and accept lower payment rates negotiated by the private insurers running Medicare Advantage Plans. This extra paperwork and limitations on care decisions frustrate many providers.
Strict Network of Providers
Medicare Advantage Plans typically have restricted provider networks, meaning patients can only see doctors and hospitals contracted with that specific plan. This limits patient choice compared to Original Medicare where you can see any provider accepting Medicare nationwide. Forced to stay in-network can disrupt care for those with complex conditions or existing doctor relationships.
Medicare Advantage Plan Financial Structure
Insurers running Medicare part c or Advantage Plan get a set payment from Medicare per enrollee, requiring them to limit spending on care. Critics argue this financial incentive leads plans to ration care. Providers feel financial factors interfere with making the best clinical decisions for patients.
Prior Authorization
Medicare Advantage Plans often require doctors to get prior authorization before ordering tests, referrals, procedures and some drugs. This adds administrative work for providers and care delays for patients. Under Original Medicare, doctors face fewer restrictions from private insurers interfering in care decisions.
Why People Are Leaving Medicare Advantage Plans
Why are people leaving Medicare Advantage Plans?
Some seniors exit Medicare Advantage Plans due to the restrictive provider networks, issues accessing care, and surprise medical bills from out-of-network providers they unknowingly saw. Seeing your doctor leave the network is another common reason for returning to Original Medicare. The hassles some face getting referrals and pre-approvals for needed care also motivate people to leave Medicare Advantage insurance plans.
These Additional Benefits Can Be Frustrating to Use
While Medicare Advantage Plans are bad because they trumpet extra benefits like dental, vision and gym memberships, the benefits often come with limitations and hassles that make them difficult to use. For example, Advantage Plans may only cover a set amount for eyewear each year, or restrict which dentists you can see for dental coverage. Accessing benefits often requires jumping through hoops according to complex rules.
Restrictive Networks
Trying to stay in a plan’s network for care can be challenging, especially for those who travel or have specialized conditions requiring top experts. Networks can be restrictive. Seniors leaving Medicare Advantage often cite the ability to see any doctor accepting Medicare as a major perk of Original Medicare that Medicare Advantage cannot match.
Cumbersome Authorizations
Prior authorizations required by Medicare Advantage for many services, tests, drugs and referrals grow burdensome for some. Approval delays interfere with care decisions. The lack of authorization requirements under Original Medicare becomes increasingly appealing for those frustrated with managed care restrictions.
Are Most People Happy with Medicare Advantage?
Low Premiums and Predictable Cost-Sharing
Surveys show most Medicare Advantage enrollees are satisfied overall, in large Part Due to the low or zero premiums along with predictable copays. Knowing costs upfront and having annual caps on out-of-pocket spending gives enrollees financial peace of mind lacking in Original Medicare. Even with provider network restrictions, many feel Medicare Advantage delivers good value.
Additional Plan Benefits
Many enrollees are attracted to Medicare Advantage Plans for benefits not included under Original Medicare like dental, vision, hearing aids, and gym memberships. These extra perks add value that seniors appreciate even if using the benefits has some limitations.
Why Do People Dislike Medicare Advantage Plans?
Those less satisfied with Medicare Advantage point to the restricted provider networks, prior authorizations, surprise bills from out-of-network providers, and hassles using additional benefits as downsides. If you frequently travel or have complex conditions requiring specialized treatment, Medicare Advantage limitations become more problematic. Detractors argue Original Medicare offers seniors greater choice and control over care decisions without interference from private insurers.
Get Help Finding a Medicare Plan That Fits Your Needs
Choosing between Original Medicare plus a Medigap Plan and Medicare Advantage involves weighing tradeoffs. Your healthcare needs and preferences should drive the decision. Some benefit more from the low costs and extra benefits of Advantage Plans, while others value Original Medicare’s flexibility and freedom to choose any doctor.
Independent brokers and state health insurance assistance programs (SHIPs) offer free, unbiased guidance on picking the right Medicare coverage. They take the time to understand your healthcare priorities and predict needs down the road. This personalized advice can provide confidence you selected suitable Medicare Plans.
Rather than make assumptions, get expert help comparing options. In-depth discussions ensure you weigh the pros and cons and find plans aligned with your healthcare priorities.
Key Disadvantages of Medicare Advantage Plans
Restrictive Networks
Advantage Plans typically have narrow provider networks. This limits specialist and hospital options compared to Original Medicare. Those who travel often or want open access to any doctor accepting Medicare find the restrictions problematic.
High Out-of-Pocket Costs
While premiums are low, Advantage Plans often have high deductibles and copays that can lead to thousands in out-of-pocket costs for extensive care. Original Medicare plus Medigap provides more financial protection.
Prior Authorization Requirements
Getting care authorized adds hassles under Advantage Plans. Approval delays can interfere with making optimal care decisions.
Plans Change Each Year
Benefits, networks, costs often fluctuate year-to-year requiring you re-evaluate and potentially switch plans each Open Enrollment.
Aggressive Marketing and Sales Tactics
High-pressure sales and misrepresentation of Advantage Plans is common. Scrutinize any plan marketed via cold calls.
What to Do Before Switching from Original Medicare to Advantage
Know Your Medicare Insurance Options
Talk to a state health insurance assistance program (SHIP) counselor to understand how Medicare Advantage differs from other paths like Medigap. Make an informed decision.
Consider Current and Future Needs
Think about your doctors, specialists required, pre-existing conditions, and how your needs may change in coming years as you age. Will an Advantage Plan suit both current and future needs?
Understand What the “Worst” Medicare Advantage Plan Looks Like for You
Know the types of restrictions that would make you dissatisfied long-term. This helps avoid plans with those limitations.
Speak with an Advisor
Discuss tradeoffs with an independent broker or SHIP counselor before joining a Medicare Advantage Plan to determine if it meets your needs.
How to Pick the Best Medicare Advantage Plan for You
Take Note of Your Needs
Consider your doctors, health conditions, prescriptions, medical services, and hospitals you require to inform plan selection.
Compare Your Options
Use Medicare.gov to compare costs, covered benefits, and provider networks across plans available in your area.
Check Plan Details Before Enrolling
Read the plan’s Evidence of Coverage and speak to a representative to clarify details. Understand the benefits, network, and costs fully before joining a Medicare Advantage Plan.
What to Do if You End Up on a Bad Medicare Advantage Plan
Use the Medicare Open Enrollment Period
Each year from October 15 to December 7, you can leave your Medicare Advantage Plan and switch back to Original Medicare. You can also enroll in a new Advantage Plan.
Use the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period
From January 1 to March 31, Medicare Advantage enrollees can switch to a different Medicare Advantage Plan or return to Original Medicare once during this window.
The Pros and Cons of Medicare Advantage Plans
Pros of Medicare Advantage Plans
- Low or no premiums
- Out-of-pocket spending limits
- Extra benefits like dental and vision
- Coordinated care model
Cons of Medicare Advantage Plans
- Restrictive provider networks
- Prior authorizations required
- Out-of-network care limits
- Opaque plan rules
How to Get More Information about Medicare Advantage Plans
To learn more about Medicare Advantage, use these key resources:
- Medicare.gov
- State Health Insurance Assistance Programs (SHIPs)
- Medicare publications like ‘Medicare & You’
- Unbiased insurance brokers or Medicare consultants
- Your State Department of Insurance
- Doctors and healthcare providers
Considering a Medicare Advantage Plan? Be Wary of Promises
Medicare Advantage Plans require scrutiny to ensure they deliver advertised benefits. Savvy enrollees ask questions to avoid pitfalls.
Subscribe to Kiplinger’s Personal Finance
Be a smarter, better informed investor. Save up to 74% off the cover price.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Stay up-to-date on the most important personal finance news and products.
Medicare Advantage Coverage, Tactics Slammed
Federal investigations find some plans exaggerate benefits, mislead enrollees.
Most Beneficiaries Happy With Medicare Advantage
But make sure you get the coverage you expect. Here’s what to ask a plan before signing up.
Some Plan Promoters Accused of Hiding Truth
Insurers pay agents based on enrollments; scrutinize promises and really study details.
Beware of MA Plans that Over Promise
To avoid pitfalls, carefully vet plans rather than just relying on marketing claims and promotions.
How to Avoid Being Misled
Ask targeted questions before enrolling to determine if a plan truly meets your needs and delivers promised benefits.
Rules For MA Promoters
New marketing requirements aim to curb misleading sales tactics. Enrollees should still verify plan details.
We’re Here to Help
You do not have to spend hours reading articles on the internet to get answers to your Medicare questions. Give Scott Sims at Sims Insurance Medicare Plans a Call at (541) 915-0939. You will get the answers you seek in a matter of minutes, with no pressure and no sales pitch. We are truly here to help.
FAQs
Are people happy with their Medicare Advantage Plans?
It varies. Some Medicare beneficiaries are satisfied with their Medicare Advantage Plans, while others are not.
Can I enroll in a Medicare Advantage Plan?
Yes, as long as you are eligible for Medicare and live in the plan’s service area, you can enroll in a Medicare Advantage Plan during specific enrollment periods.
What is the difference between Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement?
Medicare Advantage Plans, also known as Part C plans, are all-in-one alternatives to Original Medicare. They typically include prescription drug coverage and may offer additional benefits. On the other hand, Medicare Supplement Plans work alongside Original Medicare to help cover out-of-pocket costs such as deductibles and copayments.
Do many Medicare Advantage Plans require a prescription drug plan?
Yes, many Medicare Advantage Plans include prescription drug coverage as part of their benefits package. However, this may vary depending on the specific plan.
Are Medicare Advantage Plans bad for beneficiaries?
There is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question. While some beneficiaries may have negative experiences with their Medicare Advantage Plans, others find them beneficial. It is important to carefully evaluate the plans available to you and consider your own healthcare needs before making a decision.
Do Medicare Advantage Plans offer the same coverage as traditional Medicare?
Medicare Advantage Plans may offer different coverage compared to traditional Medicare. However, they must provide at least the same level of coverage as Original Medicare, and many plans offer additional benefits beyond what Original Medicare provides.
Are Medicare Advantage beneficiaries satisfied with their coverage?
It varies. Some Medicare Advantage beneficiaries are satisfied with their coverage, while others may have complaints or concerns. It is important to research and compare different plans to find the one that best meets your needs.
How many Medicare Advantage Plans are available?
The number of Medicare Advantage Plans available can vary depending on your location. Generally, there are multiple plans to choose from in most areas.
Can traditional Medicare beneficiaries enroll in a Medicare Advantage Plan?
Yes, traditional Medicare beneficiaries have the option to enroll in a Medicare Advantage Plan if they meet the eligibility requirements and live in the plan’s service area. enroll in Medicare Advantage or Medicare Part B to enjoy all benefits.
How do I enroll in a Medicare Advantage Plan?
To enroll in a Medicare Advantage Plan, you can use the Medicare Plan Finder tool on the official Medicare website, or you can contact the Medicare Advantage Plan directly. You can also enroll during specific enrollment periods, such as the Annual Enrollment Period or a Special Enrollment Period if you qualify.
